Arts and crafts as well as some pumpkin peeps centerpieces.
Wooden monster magnets to color. I got these on sale at Joanns for .12 each and added a little magnet to the back of each one. Aaron colored 3 of these and was sad that I didn’t have any more extras after the party!
Green monster juice. Strawberry/kiwi Hawaiian punch with spiders and a gummy worm. The kids liked finding the spiders. At one point, almost every child at the table had their hand in their cup, picking out their spider.