Mini Cream Pie in a Cup: Banana Cream or Lemon

A mini cream pie in a cup that come together in just minutes! A layer of graham crackers, a layer of Greek yogurt and whipped cream! Perfect for parties. This post contains affiliate links. Refer to my disclosure on the bottom of my home page for more details.

I have SUCH a huge sweet tooth in the afternoons. I can't be alone here. It's so hard to not just grab a handful of cookies or chocolate! I love yogurt though, and generally don't think of it as a dessert...unless it's in one of these mini cream pie cups. Aren't they cute? I had a bunch of these plastic cups leftover from a party and they are just the right size for an individual portion.

These mini cream pie cups would be the perfect dessert to serve at a shower or afternoon luncheon. They are simple, but so pretty at the same time. You can use whatever flavor of yogurt you'd like, but I like sticking with the pie flavors: banana cream, key lime, and lemon meringue. The tart from the lemon and lime flavors blend perfectly with the sweetness of the whipped cream.

I asked my son what he'd like for dessert for his birthday recently (my kids aren't huge fans of cake) and he said, "Can you make a pie?" I asked him what kind and he asked for key lime. I told him I hadn't ever made key lime pie before and he said, "How about those mini ones you made?" Haha, he was referring to these. I made them with key lime yogurt a few years back and he loved them. Using yogurt is a heck of a lot easier than making the real deal, but it's best to make mini pies vs. a large one unless you plan on serving it frozen so that the slices keep their shape.